THE DUTCH DISEASE EFFECT IN HIGH VS LOW OIL DEPENDENT COUNTRIES

  • JEAN-PIERRE ALLEGRET Université Paris, France
  • MOHAMED TAHAR BENKHODJA ESSCA, School of Management, France
Keywords: Dutch disease, oil exporting economy, DSGE model, Monetary Policy

Abstract

To investigate the main impacts of the recent increase of oil price on oil exporting economies, we estimate a DSGE model for a sample of 16 oil exporting countries (Algeria, Argentina, Ecuador, Gabon, Indonesia, Kuwait, Libya, Malaysia, Mexico, Nigeria, Oman, Russia, Saudi Arabia, United Arab Emirates, and Venezuela) over the period from 1980 to 2010, except for Russia where our sample begins in 1992. In order to distinguish between high-dependent and low-dependent countries, we use two indicators: the ratio of fuel exports to total merchandise export and the ratio of oil exports to GDP. We verify if the first group is more sensitive to the Dutch disease effect. We also assess the role of monetary policy.

Our main findings are twofold. First, our results confirm the fact that the Dutch disease occurs mainly in high oil dependent countries. More precisely, we find that the manufacturing production decreases in the aftermath of a positive oil price shock in six countries (on eight) of our first sample while only Mexico suffers from a Dutch disease in the sample of low oil dependent economies. Second, the appropriate monetary policy rule -exchange rate rule versus inflation targeting one-to prevent the Dutch disease differs according to the countries. In other words, the best monetary rule is specific to each country.

References

REFERENCES

Acosta, P.A., Lartey, E.K.K., Mandelman, F.S., (2009). Remittances and the Dutch Disease. Journal of international economics. 79:102-116.

Aizenman J., Sebastian E., and Riera-Crichton D. (2012), Adjustment Patterns to Commodity Terms of Trade Shocks: The Role of Exchange Rate and International Reserves Policies, 01-10-2012, Department of Economics, UCSC, UC Santa Cruz.

Almeida, V. (2009). Bayesian Estimation of a DSGE Model for the Portuguese Economy. Working Papers w200914, Banco de Portugal.

Ambler, S., Dib, A., and Rebei, N., (2003). Nominal Rigidities and Exchange Rate Pass-Through in a Structural Small Open Economy Model. Working Papers 03-29, Bank of Canada.

Ambler, S., Dib, A., and Rebei, N., (2004). Optimal Taylor Rules in an Estimated Model of a Small Open Economy. Working Papers 04-36, Bank of Canada.

Arezki R., Gylfason T., and Sy A. (editors) (2011), Beyong the Curse, Policies to Harness the Power of Natural Resources, International Monetary Fund, Washington D.C.


Bénassy-Quéré A., Batté L., Carton B., and Dufrénot G. (2010), Asymmetric Terms-of-Trade Shocks in a Monetary Union: An Application to West Africa, Journal of African Economies 19(5): 657-690.

Benkhodja, M.T., (2011). Monetary Policy and the Dutch Disease Effects in a Small Open Oil Exporting Economy. International Economics 138: 78-102.

Ben Aïssa, M.S & Rebei, N, (2012). Price Subsidies and the Conduct of Monetary Policy. Journal of Macroeconomics, 34(3), pages 769-787.

Brahmbhatt M., Canuto O., and Vostroknutova E. (2010), Dealing with Dutch disease, Economic Premise, No 16, June, The World Bank, Washington D.C.

Calvo, G. (1983). Staggered Prices in a Utility-Maximizing Framework. Journal of Monetary Economics. 12:383-398.

Céspedes L.F. and Velasco A. (2012), Macroeconomic Performance¸ During Commodity Price Booms and Busts, NBER Working Paper, No. 18569, November.

Corden, W.M., and J.P., Neary (1982). Booming Sector and De-Industrialisation in a Small Open Economy. Economic Journal 92:825-848.

Corden, W., (1984). Booming Sector and Dutch Disease Economics: Survey and Consolidation. Oxford Economic Papers, 36: 359–80.

Del Negro, M., and Schorfheide, F., (2008). Forming Priors for DSGE Models (and How It Affects the Assessment of Nominal Rigidities). Journal of Monetary Economics, 55(7), pages 1191-1208, October.

De Resende, C., Dib, A., Kichian, M., (2010). Alternative Optimized Monetary Policy Rules in Multi-Sector Small Open Economies: The Role of Real Rigidities. Bank of Canada working paper 2010-9.

Devereux, M., P. R. Lane, and J. Xu (2006). Exchange Rate and Monetary Policy in Emerging Market Economies. The Economic Journal, 116: 478–506.

Dib, A., (2008). Welfare Effects of Commodity Price and Exchange Rate Volatilities in a Multi-Sector Small Open Economy Model. Bank of Canada working paper 2008-8.

Dib, A., (2003). An Estimated Canadian DSGE Model With Nominal and Real Rigidities. Canadian Journal of Economics, 36(4), pages 949-972, November.

Dib, A., Mendicino, C., Zhang, Y., (2008). Price Level Targeting in a Small Open Economy with Financial Frictions: Welfare Analysis. Bank of Canada working paper 2008-40.

Egert B. and Leonard C.S. (2008), Dutch Disease Scare in Kazakhstan: Is it real?, Open Economies Review, 19(2):147–165.

Erceg, C., Henderson, D., Levin, A., (2000). Optimal Monetary Policy With Staggered Wage and Price Contracts. Journal of Monetary Economics 46, 281–313.

Fernández-Villaverde, J. (2010). The Econometrics of DSGE Models. Journal of the Spanish Economic Association, SERIEs (2010) 1:3–49.

Frankel J.A. (2011), A Comparison of Product Price Targeting and Other Monetary Anchor Options for Commodity Exporters in Latin America, Economia, 12(1): 1-57.

Gertler M., S. Gilchrist and F. Natalucci (2007). External Constraints on Monetary Policy and the Financial Accelator. Journal of Money, Credit and Banking. 39(2-3): 295–330.

Harding T. and Venables A.J. (2011), Foreign Exchange Windfalls, Imports and Exports. Oxcarre Research Paper, February, University of Oxford.

Ismail K. (2010), The Structural Manifestation of the ‘Dutch Disease’: The Case of Oil Exporting Countries, IMF Working Paper, WP/10/103, April.

Jahan-Parvar, M.R., and Mohammadi, H., (2008). Oil Prices and Real Exchange Rates in Oil-Exporting Countries: A Bounds Testing Approach. MPRA Paper 13435, University Library of Munich, Germany.

Lama R and Madina P (2012). Is Exchange Rate Stabilization an Appropriate Cure for the Dutch Disease? International Journal of Central Banking. 85(1): 5-46.

Lartey, E.K.K, (2008). Capital Inflows, Dutch Disease Effects and Monetary Policy in a Small Open Economy. Review of international economics. 16:5 671-689.

Medina, J.P., and Soto, C., (2005). Oil Shocks and Monetary Policy in an Estimated DSGE Model for a Small Open Economy. Central Bank of Chile, Working Paper No 353.

Mendoza E.G. (1995), The Terms of Trade, the Rela Exchange Rate, and Economic Fluctuations, International Economic Review. 36(1): 101-137.
Oomes, N., and Kalcheva, K., (2007). Diagnosing Dutch Disease: Does Russia Have the Symptoms? IMF Working Papers 07/102, International Monetary Fund.

Ploeg F. van der (2011), Natural Resources: Curse or Blessing? Journal of Economic Literature, 49(2): 366-420.

Ploeg F. van der and Poelhekke S. (2009). Volatility and the Natural Resource Curse. Oxford Economic Papers. 61(4): 727-760.

Kose M.A. (2002), Explaining Business Cycles in Small Open Economies: How Much Do World Prices Matter? Journal of International Economics. 56(2): 299-327.

Rabanal, P., and Rubio-Ramirez, J.F., (2005). Comparing New Keynesian Models of the Business Cycle: A Bayesian Approach. Journal of Monetary Economics. 52(6): 1151-1166.

Sosunov, K., and Zamulin, O., (2007). Monetary Policy in an Economy Sick with Dutch Disease.Working Papers W0101, Center for Economic and Financial Research (CEFIR).

Schmitt-Grohé, S. and M. Uribe. (2003). Closing Small Open Economy Models. Journal of International Economics. 61: 163-185.

Schmitt-Grohé, S. and M. Uribe. (2004). Solving Dynamic General Equilibrium Models Using a Second–Order Approximation to the Policy Function. Journal of Economic Dynamics and Control. 28 (4): 755–75.

Schmitt Grohé. S and M. Uribe (2007). Optimal, Simple, and Implementable Monetary and Fiscal Rules. Journal of Monetary Economics. 54: 1702–25.

Sungbae, A. and F. Schorfheide (2007). Bayesian Analysis of DSGE Models. Econo-metric Reviews. 26(2-4): 113-172.

Yun, T., (1996). Nominal Price Rigidity, Money Supply Endogeneity, and the Business Cycles. Journal of Monetary Economics. 37:345-370.
Published
2015-11-19
Section
Articles